Using a Sprite Sheet Makes Blurry Sprites

I noticed that using a spritesheet for my sprites makes the image blurry or fuzzy. I don't have this problem with individual sprites, but making a sheet individual sprites would be quite a cumbersome task.

I have Filter mode set to Point and no compression on the sprite sheet.

Here's an image comparison. The left image is an individual sprite that I cut out of the spritesheet. https://i.imgur.com/kXUoozl.png