koobas.hobune.stream
Controlling the curvature of a Bézier curve
Hey guys,
I've been working on a curve generator for my game. I'm using it to plot a course for a ship.
First a little background; our ships have a maximum rotation of x and can move a maximum range of y per turn. They apply this range and rotation over a number of time segments, using either, neither or both types of transformation in each time segment.
While they can turn on their centre, it is optimal if they move and rotate at the same time where ever possible, however moving and rotating enforces a turning circle. With that in mind, I would like to control the curvature of my Bézier curve in order to find the optimal route from A to B while maintaining a specfic heading at both the start and end of the route.
I realised that the vector between the first point and the second point represents the starting heading and that the vector between the penultimate point and the last point control the end heading. I've also noticed that the distance between P0/P1 and P2/P3 controls the curvature (the closer the distance, the tighter the turn).
Taking into account all of the above, I have created a generator which creates a path between two points forcing a specified start and end heading and which (by use of colour) tells me if the curvature is to steep for a particular ship's turn ratio.
In this case, both the start and end heading are 315 (or -45).
I've been experimenting with changing the curve by adding in extra control points in between P1 and p2. This allows me to manually widen the curve reducing the tightness of the turn but I need to find some formula/algorithm for placing these extra control points which allows these curves be loosened/tightened automatically.
I was hoping someone could point me in the direction of some maths that might help?
Thanks in advance.
In general it is not an easy task to control the curvature of a Bezier curve. If you look into the Bezier curvature formula you get, k(t) = (px_d py_dd - py_d px_dd)/(px_d^2 + py_d^2)3/2. As you see you need second derivative to control the curvature. It means without acceleration constrains you don't have meaningful control over the curvature. So at least 4th order Bezier is necessary for your task. I don't know any a-z approach to give you Bezier though. If you got it by now please share it with me.
It was taking me to long to complete, so in the end, I created a system where if after trying a few different things(changing the distance of p1 and p2) to get a valid curve, if I haven't found one, it puts in extra points which cause the ship to stop and rotate on the spot before continuing on the curve.
Eventually, I'll come back to it when I have more time, the system I have isn't good enough, but for now it works.
TL;DR: Haven't found a solution, put in a placeholder system for now until I have more time to spend on it.
As telcom_un mentioned, Bezier curves at their simplest aren't the easiest to control. But thankfully, you're in an area of math which has a very rich toolkit of other curve functions you can use which might make it easier for you to control the curve. :)
Bezier curves are actually just a special case of the more general "Non-Uniform Rational Basis Spline", or NURBS curves for short. NURBS curves allow you to specify weights for the control points which, in layman's terms, behaves like gravity in that they pull the curve further towards them the higher the weight. If a point's weight is infinite, the curve passes through that point, regardless of where it is.
There is also another type of curve function called "Cubic Hermite Splines", which has a variant known as "Catmull-Rom Splines". These curves naturally pass through all the control points, and bend nicely in between.
Catmull-Rom splines is what Eric5h5 implemented for his Vectrosity Library, which can draw this type of curve in Unity, and which I've used extensively. :)
(Don't take that last part as an ad, I don't work for Eric or am affiliated with him in any way, I just like his library and can recommend it.)
