How to make a for loop display inventory correctly?

I've been stuck on this issue a while now, I have a working inventory and shop system, however when I try to display it with GUI, it comes out wrong. Here's a pic of what's currently in the inventory(added at runtime from the shop).

Here is the script that's supposed to loop through it:

 for(loopInt = 0; loopInt < inventoryContents.Count; loopInt++)
         {
             InventoryItem inventoryItemScript = inventoryItem.GetComponent<InventoryItem>();
             if(targetPath.transform.childCount >= inventoryContents.Count)
             {
                 targetPath.transform.GetChild(targetPath.transform.childCount);    //Prevents clones
                 gridControlScript.Reposition();        //Organizes the inv with NGUI's grid
                 inventoryItemScript.UpdateInfo();    //Makes sure all the info is correct
             }
             else
             {
                 NGUITools.AddChild(targetPath, inventoryItem);
                 inventoryItemScript.item.itemName = inventoryContents[loopInt].itemName;
                 inventoryItemScript.item.icon = inventoryContents[loopInt].icon;
                 inventoryItemScript.UpdateInfo();        //Makes sure all the info is correct
                 gridControlScript.Reposition();            //Organizes the inv with NGUI's grid
             }
         }

NGUITools.AddChild is basically like instantiate but optimized for NGUI. gridControlScript.Reposition() is not important, just an NGUI thing that organizes the buttons.

Here is what inventoryItemScript.UpdateInfo() does:

 public void UpdateInfo()
     {
         itemNameTag = transform.Find("Item Text");
         itemNameTag.GetComponent<UILabel>().text = item.itemName;
         itemIcon = transform.Find("Texture");
         itemIcon.GetComponent<UITexture>().mainTexture = item.icon;
     }

I've checked and it does find the right Game Objects at runtime. However it doesn't seem to be getting the right info from the inventory for loop. Here's a pic in the inspector:

What's even odder is that this is what I actually see in the game screen:

All the info is completely different! And I have no idea why.