Player 1 and Player 2 move together

I have a separate script for player 1 and player 2, but they act like they are both interpreting the same controls from my one controller. When I take the P2 script off the second character, player 2 will not move. If I take the Player 1 script off of player 1, player 2 still moves.

Here is my Player 1 script:

  // Determine the angle of the left thumbstick
  var xAxis = Input.GetAxis("L_XAxis_1");
  var yAxis = Input.GetAxis("L_YAxis_1");
  
  //reset rotation so rigidbodies don't get flipped
  transform.rotation = Quaternion.identity;
  
  //find the target to move towards
  var xtarget = transform.position.x + xAxis;
  var ytarget = transform.position.y + yAxis;
  var target = Vector3(xtarget, ytarget, 0);
  
  // The step size is equal to speed times frame time.
  //This finds how hard the player is pushing the joystick, and changes speed
  speed = Vector2(xAxis, yAxis).magnitude * 4 ;
  var step = speed * Time.deltaTime;
  
  // Move our position a step closer to the target.
  transform.position = Vector3.MoveTowards(transform.position, target, step);

And here is my Player 2 script:

  // Determine the angle of the left thumbstick
  var xAxis = Input.GetAxis("L_XAxis_2");
  var yAxis = Input.GetAxis("L_YAxis_2");
  
  //reset rotation so rigidbodies don't get flipped
  transform.rotation = Quaternion.identity;
  
  //find the target to move towards
  var xtarget = transform.position.x + xAxis;
  var ytarget = transform.position.y + yAxis;
  var target = Vector3(xtarget, ytarget, 0);
  
  // The step size is equal to speed times frame time.
  //This finds how hard the player is pushing the joystick, and changes speed
  speed = Vector2(xAxis, yAxis).magnitude * 4 ;
  var step = speed * Time.deltaTime;
  
  // Move our position a step closer to the target.
  transform.position = Vector3.MoveTowards(transform.position, target, step);

Here is the input for movement (only showed left x axis, because it's a big picture):

Here is the player 1 gameobject:

And here is the player 2 gameobject:

Do you see where the problem might be? My controller seems to work fine.