toggle group bug

My toggle group is "working" The default is 0 with options up to 5 whenever i open the window with the toggle group it swtiches to "1" When I close it, regardless of the toggle I choose, it switches to "5"

My open button is not linked to a number and my close button is not linked to a number

Character Toggle Control Sccript

 public class ToggleCharacter : MonoBehaviour
 {
       public void ChosenNinja(int newNinja)
      {
            CharacterSelectionManager.character.activeNinja = newNinja;
      }
  }

The control for opening and closing windows that hold the toggle buttons themselves

public class ShopWindowButton : MonoBehaviour {

 public GameObject Upgrades; //the windows containing buttons n toggles
 public GameObject IAP;
 public GameObject Characters;
 public GameObject Supers;

 public GameObject UpgradesButton;  // the buttons that open or close those windows
 public GameObject IAPButton;
 public GameObject CharactersButton;
 public GameObject SupersButton;
 public GameObject HomeButton;


 public void ClosePanel()
 {
     Upgrades.SetActive(false);
     IAP.SetActive(false);
     Characters.SetActive(false);
     Supers.SetActive(false);
     UpgradesButton.SetActive(true);
     IAPButton.SetActive(true);
     CharactersButton.SetActive(true);
     SupersButton.SetActive(true);
     HomeButton.SetActive(true);
 }

 public void OpenCharacter()
 {
     Upgrades.SetActive(false);
     IAP.SetActive(false);
     Characters.SetActive(true);
     Supers.SetActive(false);
     UpgradesButton.SetActive(false);
     IAPButton.SetActive(false);
     CharactersButton.SetActive(false);
     SupersButton.SetActive(false);
     HomeButton.SetActive(false);
 }

there are 3 other methods that open the other 3 windows which I've removed those for simple readability

lastly a photo of the editor and how the toggle script is applied to each of the character selections