man..
I felt like writing a review for this -after two years- well I gotta say masterpiece was TOAS' StoneCold n SmilingIdiot did great as well. and all others too.
SOOOOO.... When ll we able to see Song Art Project 2 thread?? >=/
Our goal is for Newgrounds to be ad free for everyone! Become a Supporter today and help make this dream a reality!
The Song Art Project!
How this collab worked:
I listed 20 song titles, and users were to draw a picture based on the song title (not the song itself, but a few have bent this rule). The layout is easily browsable, and intructions are on the main page! Please read them.
Everyone likes reviews, except for harsh ones. Please use constructive critism! (we also love positive reviews! :D)
- The Song Art Project Crew
man..
I felt like writing a review for this -after two years- well I gotta say masterpiece was TOAS' StoneCold n SmilingIdiot did great as well. and all others too.
SOOOOO.... When ll we able to see Song Art Project 2 thread?? >=/
Cool.
The idea for this collab was cool, and for the most part, the submission itself was done really well. The graphics were great and I loved most if not all of the parts of this collab. Truly something great made here, and it really entertained well. NIce work.
It was pretty good
It was an awesome collab, but it would be awesome if you click on a pic & it plays the song
Now this is the sort of art collabs id like to see
It was entertaining and fun to browse thru the great pics. My favs are my man Havayosunu, TOAS, UnderARock, Amyeh, Saza and StoneColdSoul. But shit, that Seek & Destroy pic is da bomb, literally lol. What i miss is the way you guys could set up the tracks (i dont know shit about actionscripts). There was only one track looping, so yeah it wouldve been even cooler if i could click on a title, and both track and pic would come up. But nonetheless, this collab seems quite awesome, im gonna fav it. Hurrah for a good organized collab :D
5'd.
Not bad at all
Never caught it before, but Havay's Seek and Destroy was rather ace.
Collab wise, I was expecting a dodgy slide show, but you've done a great job with the selection menu, so I'll salute you for that!
Everyone says you need to show the music, which I can agree with, but it'll also jack up the file size. Maybe some short sound clips would work.
Other thing is maybe giving free choice on songs :s I don't know if they were important to you, or if you tried for free range of music, but there wasn't any dance music, and I was dead lucky to get the one I most wanted!
Great thing about music is that there'll always be a song that'll be proper epic to people and conjures up imagery, even differing person to person!
Overall a decent art collab for sure, defo fun to do.
Thanks for the amazing review. But just to say - even having samples would add an extra 2mb weight. The thing is, it wasnt about the song - but the TITLE of the song.
Thanks for the menu feedback. ANd thanks for taking part.